IDGuy
IDGuy
  • 415
  • 25 604 886
Why this Watch is the Very Best and Worst of Omega...
A Discussion around the Gloss Black Omega Seamaster Aqua Terra and why it is the Very Best and Worst of Modern Omega. From the variety of sizes to being simple, elegant & utilitarian. The New Micro-Adjust clasp system and the stunning jet black dial that'll offer a lot of versatility. This watch has it all but it also lacks the big innovations to elevate this piece to a higher standard.
#omega #omegawatches #aquaterra
0:00 Intro
1:18 Black Gloss Dial
2:33 The Best
4:16 The Worst
5:47 Innovation & Omega "Ultra light"
6:55 Design & Render
7:33 Conclusion
All Images are Sourced from either Press Release Photos or Public Listings.
Below are a list of the common sources that are used in no particular order:
Bob’s Watches | Revolution Watch | HQ Milton | Hodinkee | Monochrome Watches | Jomashop | Analog Shift | Bulang and Sons | Robb Report | Watchfinder | WatchBox | Phillips Watches | Christies | Timekeepers Club | Fratello Watches | Bexsonn | Worn and Wound | A Collected Man | Oracle Time | Time + Tide Watches
IDGuy Store: teespring.com/stores/the-idguy-store
Support the Channel: www.patreon.com/idguy
Follow me on Instagram: id.guy?hl=en
Contact me: enquire.idguy@gmail.com
Переглядів: 15 837

Відео

Do You Really Need a GMT Watch + Why Are We Mad About Them?
Переглядів 13 тис.День тому
A Discussion around the GMT / Dual Time Watch. The modern watch world seems obsessed with pursuing the GMT complication but the question is why? Status, Design, Function, there are many reasons why these watches are so well received. Is it because brands themselves consider the GMT to be a Premium Product or is there something more? #gmtwatch #gmt #rolexgmt All Images are Sourced from either Pr...
10 Things I Wish I Knew About Watch Collecting Before Starting
Переглядів 25 тис.14 днів тому
A Discussion around the 10 Things that I wish I'd Known about Watch Collecting before Starting. Everything from looking for simpler pieces, buying better straps, putting money aside when the inevitable service bill arrives or when lightning strikes. This hobby teaches us a lot of things along the way but the biggest take home is to approach it with an open mind (and to enjoy the highs and lows)...
My First Rolex + Love/Hate Relationship with the Explorer (124270 Hands-On Review)
Переглядів 36 тис.21 день тому
A Review of my 36mm Rolex Explorer ref. 124270. After covering this watch and the many evolutions of the Explorer for what must be 5 years, to finally own one and appreciate the subtleties of the newest reference has made the experience so cathartic. From its extremely wearable size and discretion its to well executed dial, there's nothing about this watch that makes you yearn for more. One les...
What's Really Going on with Rolex & Precious Metals? (Waitlist + The Gold Trend)
Переглядів 16 тис.Місяць тому
A Discussion around Rolex and Precious (Gold) Metals. Virtually every piece under the sun that the brand seems to be promoting and producing today is either in Gold or Two-Tone. This years Watches and Wonders are a clear sign that the brand is trying their utmost to promote precious metals over Stainless Steel. But what does that mean for the future of the brand? Moving upmarket, better PPU sal...
Ranking My Top-10 Favourite Longines Watches (Heritage Collection)
Переглядів 25 тис.Місяць тому
A Discussion and Ranking of my Top 10 Favourite Longines Watches. From Classic Minimal Sector dials, to Military Field watches and Dressier Chronographs, the brand covers everything and it's very difficult to not find one watch that doesn't appeal to us. #longines #longineswatches Intro 0:00 Why Should We Follow Longines? 1:02 No. 12 Legend Diver 1:51 No. 11 Heritage 1945 2:55 No. 10 Heritage M...
Tudor’s Quietest Release? Pelagos FXD “Darth Vader” Chrono (Cycling Edition)
Переглядів 21 тис.Місяць тому
A Discussion around the Tudor Pelagos FXD Pro Cycling "Darth Vader". A model that arrived but has not received the attention it deserves. From a design standpoint, with so much attention put into the details as well as building on the FXD Platform, this is one of Tudor's best releases of the year. I'd even say it manages to hold its own next to the original Pelagos FXD as a completely different...
What has Happened to ORIS Watches...
Переглядів 25 тис.Місяць тому
A Discussion around Oris Watches and their disappearance of popularity on this platform. Remember 5 - 6 years ago when Oris was always a huge talking point in the watch community? In recent years though they seemed to have dropped off the map and we're left asking why. From changing prices, moving in-house with movements and designs that have not evolved, these are just a few reasons why we are...
Is This Tudor's Answer to the Rolex Submariner? (Black Bay 41 Monochrome)
Переглядів 45 тис.2 місяці тому
A Discussion around the Tudor "Monochrome" Black Bay 41mm. One of the most subtle releases from the brand in a long time but in fact the simplicity is what has won so many people over. Almost a decade since the brand last gave us a B&W Black Bay Diver - is this Tudor's answer to the Rolex Submariner? Now with so many brands raising their prices but still not delivering on every detail, a simple...
The Good (and Bad) About Zenith's NEW Defy Divers...
Переглядів 10 тис.2 місяці тому
A Discussion around Zenith's Defy Diver (Extreme & Revival) After years of waiting, Zenith has finally returned to producing Dive Watches again. And in typical fashion they are bold and very interesting. But the question is whether they may have made these pieces too contemporary for a modern audience? #IDGuy #zenith #zenithwatches Intro 0:00 Defying Watch Design 0:34 Zenith Watches and Wonders...
In-Depth Rolex & Tudor 2024 Official Releases Critique (BB58 GMT, Gold Deepsea, Grey GMT)
Переглядів 31 тис.2 місяці тому
A Discussion and Review of the 2024 Rolex and Tudor Releases from Watches and Wonders. One of the most lacklustre years in recent memory and probably a hangover from 2021 / 2022 planning. Where Rolex focused their efforts on producing a wide range of pieces in precious metals, Tudor continued to deliver Black Bays with one surprise being the Black Bay Fifty-Eight GMT, a fan favourite. #watchesa...
Why is Nobody Talking About the 42mm Blancpain Fifty Fathoms?
Переглядів 21 тис.2 місяці тому
A Discussion around the 42mm Blancpain Fifty Fathoms. After what must be 10 years, we've finally received a mainline production model that is smaller than 45mm's. So why is it that nobody seems to be talking about it? Is it because of the recent Swatch Scuba collaboration? Or that watch looks almost identical to the 45mm variant? A combination of its price and its design? Maybe it's a mix of al...
The Tudor Watch We're All Waiting For...
Переглядів 47 тис.2 місяці тому
Predictions and Renders around the Updated Tudor Black Bay GMT. Judging by what Tudor has produced recently (with new case, bracelet and movements) the GMT is going to be here soon. Whether it will be a Black Bay Fifty-Eight GMT, or maybe a Pelagos? There is plenty of potential for what they might produce next: from a Fuchsia Bezel insert to a Roulette Date Window and a METAS Certified Movement...
Tudor's NEXT Chronograph? Prince "Big Block" Release Predictions (with Renders)
Переглядів 19 тис.3 місяці тому
A Discussion around Tudor's next Chronograph - The Prince Chronograph "Big Block". There's no guessing when we'll see it arrive in their collection but it will be here sooner than later. At a time where the Rolex Daytona has recently recieved and update, Tudor will be doing the same. Debuting their In-House MT59XX caliber with three sub-dials and date function in a watch that could range anywhe...
Is This Actually the Omega Speedmaster We’ve Wanted?
Переглядів 46 тис.3 місяці тому
A Discussion around the Omega Speedmaster Professional White Dial. A Speedmaster that will appeal to those who want an alternative look to their watch with a more modern edge or someone wanting that "Yang" to the Black Dials "Yin". Why is this design a success? Because it is obvious. It is a style that is going be relevant from now until the end of time. #omega #omegawatches #omegaspeedmaster I...
Omega to Discontinue the Railmaster... What's Next?
Переглядів 48 тис.3 місяці тому
Omega to Discontinue the Railmaster... What's Next?
Rolex’s Next Generation Milgauss Predictions (with Designs & Renders)
Переглядів 17 тис.4 місяці тому
Rolex’s Next Generation Milgauss Predictions (with Designs & Renders)
Tudor's "Leaked" Updated Black Bay Fifty-Eight? + Predictions (with Renders)
Переглядів 68 тис.4 місяці тому
Tudor's "Leaked" Updated Black Bay Fifty-Eight? Predictions (with Renders)
The Outstanding Revival of the TAG Heuer Carrera (Glassbox, Skipper, Dato)
Переглядів 13 тис.4 місяці тому
The Outstanding Revival of the TAG Heuer Carrera (Glassbox, Skipper, Dato)
Will Rolex Discontinue The Pepsi GMT? (Coke Bezel Returns)
Переглядів 29 тис.5 місяців тому
Will Rolex Discontinue The Pepsi GMT? (Coke Bezel Returns)
The New Omega Speedmaster "Dark Side of the Moon" Apollo 8 (is Kitsch)
Переглядів 28 тис.5 місяців тому
The New Omega Speedmaster "Dark Side of the Moon" Apollo 8 (is Kitsch)
Zenith Defy: Why it's the Most Misunderstood Sports Watch
Переглядів 12 тис.5 місяців тому
Zenith Defy: Why it's the Most Misunderstood Sports Watch
The Concerning Future of Watch Price Increases...
Переглядів 40 тис.5 місяців тому
The Concerning Future of Watch Price Increases...
IDGuy’s SOTC State of the Watch Collection 2024 (Rolex, Zenith, Omega, Tudor, Seiko)
Переглядів 44 тис.5 місяців тому
IDGuy’s SOTC State of the Watch Collection 2024 (Rolex, Zenith, Omega, Tudor, Seiko)
The No.1 Thing Everybody HATES About Modern Tudor Watches...
Переглядів 25 тис.6 місяців тому
The No.1 Thing Everybody HATES About Modern Tudor Watches...
What Are The Best Watch Releases of 2023? (40+ Watches & Year Recap)
Переглядів 53 тис.6 місяців тому
What Are The Best Watch Releases of 2023? (40 Watches & Year Recap)
What Happened to the Omega Seamaster Planet Ocean? (Evolution, Thickness, Price)
Переглядів 48 тис.6 місяців тому
What Happened to the Omega Seamaster Planet Ocean? (Evolution, Thickness, Price)
Has Longines Perfected The 39mm Legend Diver? + Return of Mid-Size Watches
Переглядів 29 тис.7 місяців тому
Has Longines Perfected The 39mm Legend Diver? Return of Mid-Size Watches
I Was WRONG About This Seiko - SJE093 "62MAS" Re-Edition (Review)
Переглядів 39 тис.7 місяців тому
I Was WRONG About This Seiko - SJE093 "62MAS" Re-Edition (Review)
What is the Future of the Tudor Black Bay Pro? (METAS, Next Generation)
Переглядів 26 тис.7 місяців тому
What is the Future of the Tudor Black Bay Pro? (METAS, Next Generation)

КОМЕНТАРІ

  • @MaestroDeca
    @MaestroDeca 16 годин тому

    I disagree with you here. This is everything you’ve said you wanted from a release. Back to basics omega. It’s as basic as it gets while improving the design. The only issue is thickness. And high polish is definitely a preference but I can see your point there

  • @miabeatz80
    @miabeatz80 17 годин тому

    If Omega already tried the matte approach with the railmaster and received sub par reviews for it why make the same watch for aqua Terra? Also why do some brands get praised for slow change yet people want a 360° change on every Omega model. This is why isn't impossible to please watch critics. The only issues the aqua Terra had, sizes and bracelet, were fixed here but still no applause?

  • @christianaviles2199
    @christianaviles2199 17 годин тому

    Fully brushed would be great. Honestly I'd be ecstatic with just brushed center links even if they kept the other ares polished. Oh and a good hardness coating.

  • @chrishine8699
    @chrishine8699 18 годин тому

    Outstanding video as always. I think your proposal of the extrapolation of the features and components from the titanium version being a reality could truly be a huge thing if Omega elected to do so. They listen to some things… could someone from Omega look at that? Man would that be a game changer! Cheers!

  • @samuelkim2611
    @samuelkim2611 18 годин тому

    No good !!!

  • @dukes70
    @dukes70 18 годин тому

    Love the dial choice and new style bracelet but agree on why the need for an all polished case. Plus that micro adjust is horrible. It leaves a gap between the links that looks like a $50 watch. As a design guy I’m stunned to hear you say it’s brilliant!! 🤦‍♂️🤦‍♂️🤦‍♂️ It’s a huge miss for them. Credit for trying but they missed badly where they could have put some effort into it. Who on that team looked at this and said “yes, this is it”? Also I don’t see this as competing with the Explorer, but more with the DateJust. Just when I thought I’d buy one, I’ll wait…again!

  • @akinigiri
    @akinigiri 18 годин тому

    I have a 2008 Aqua Terra with a black gloss dial. It is baffling that it went away for a such a while

  • @HaonProductions
    @HaonProductions 19 годин тому

    There's something very dressy about that gloss black, especially with that bracelet. I'm actually a bit annoyed it doesn't come in a 36 which is my ideal for that kind of watch... maybe I should just finally get a datejust

  • @ColinLack
    @ColinLack 20 годин тому

    Right now I imagine that tech we all want is still too expensive to trickle down to the more affordable range. I bet in 2 years we'll see some of it trickle down. TBH though I am disappointed in this watch as I like the teak dials but they don't offer them in the sizing I like in the colour I like. That's my issue with the AT line. The models I like and find interesting? Typically only offered in 41mm. When I need a 36/38mm.

  • @tpop3723
    @tpop3723 20 годин тому

    Omega pulled a Seiko.

  • @mrdisco99
    @mrdisco99 20 годин тому

    Saying mass produced is not real watchmaking is just snobby gatekeeping. There's no reason to put up barriers to appreciating any kind of watchmaking.

  • @BenMwatches
    @BenMwatches 20 годин тому

    People will buy this - but polished case makes it more a dress piece and alrounder I think it’s just another omega

  • @warrenbrenner4972
    @warrenbrenner4972 21 годину тому

    "Takes a licking and keeps on ticking " used in a TIMEX watch TV ad in the mid 1960's

  • @itsgarrick4910
    @itsgarrick4910 21 годину тому

    You really stand out amongst all other watch channels with your recreations. Thank you much!

  • @dannysimenauer5745
    @dannysimenauer5745 21 годину тому

    I own 5 Omegas, but not the Aqua Terra. First, the assymetric hands. Either put the arrow head on both hands or remove it entirely. The second problem is the pastel colors. I prefer the bolder colors like Rolex or the Citizen Tsuyosa dials. If Omega would make a green dial in 40/41 MM, I would ignore the mono arrow hand and buy it.

  • @EdwardViaTomato
    @EdwardViaTomato 21 годину тому

    It's lovely.

  • @jeremydahm2124
    @jeremydahm2124 21 годину тому

    The 38s are very sharp but too dressy for my taste. All that polished surface looks a bit tacky almost. But that bracelet is very good.

  • @JDP-88
    @JDP-88 21 годину тому

    The AT line is going after the OP/DJ My prediction is a new Railmaster will be the rival to the Explorer. It’ll be fully brushed compared to fully polished to justify needing both an AT and Railmaster

  • @rabtrekker
    @rabtrekker 22 години тому

    If this had a rotating bezel, take my money. But that would never happen 😅

  • @fatherartifact6927
    @fatherartifact6927 22 години тому

    As an Omega guy I love the Aqua Terra. Have 2 of them.

  • @kevinr206
    @kevinr206 22 години тому

    So many colors, but no no date option? And, when something actually new? Where is the 165.024 ?

  • @BigFerg-hf6uv
    @BigFerg-hf6uv 22 години тому

    Omega Railmaster silver face on bracelet. The watch is entirely brushed. One of the best watches in Omega's line up. Amazing watch similar to the Aquà Terra but without all the blingy shine or date window.

  • @al-knows-nothing
    @al-knows-nothing 22 години тому

    Superb vid, as usual :) It’s very similar and a kind-of reissue of my 36mm 2518.50 quartz (and the automatic they released near that) which I love..moreso than this actually as mine is 36mm and doesn’t have the numbers around the minute track which is a pet peeve of mine on watches like this). I do like the date being in the centre-line on this though… Anyone in the market should _consider_ the neo-vintage model and save on the bucks. It’s kind of like buying a neo-vintage Datejust…

  • @Sandouras
    @Sandouras 23 години тому

    Regarding innovation: why innovate? Rolex proves that it doesn’t come down to innovation, but clout and recognition. Why spend money on innovation if nobody is gonna buy your product? I also found that telescopic crown weird.

  • @darrenhojnacki6636
    @darrenhojnacki6636 23 години тому

    I think that the titanium, telescopic crown etc is what should be on the Railmaster. I know they discontinued it, but in 2027 for the 70th anniversary they should bring it back with this. The Aquaterra has been more dress/sports to me, so I get the polish v brushed finishing

  • @chrisa950
    @chrisa950 23 години тому

    Such a good point regarding the polished bracelet which adds feminism to the watch which is unneeded especially if you take into consideration the beauty of the brushed bracelet of the Globemaster.

  • @michaelbradley6488
    @michaelbradley6488 23 години тому

    I love it, something very timeless about a simple black dial.

  • @r7coo
    @r7coo 23 години тому

    The Railmaster blows it out of the water for me

  • @TheMegsie1
    @TheMegsie1 23 години тому

    Pel..aaa..gos. Not Pella-gos

  • @stephan384
    @stephan384 День тому

    Disagree here on the full polish. Just as it should be, versatile. Would hope for a Railmaster version like the older Aqua Terra.

  • @markthespark25
    @markthespark25 День тому

    I think that the Teak variants are more unique relative to the Shades collection. Quite frankly I am a fan of a watch having its own design motif - the shark tooth indices coupled with the teak dial is iconic. When Omega transitioned to the Shades collection, to me it came across as too similar to an Oyster Perpetual. Rather than shifting its dial design, I would prefer that Omega released the AT in an updated 38/39 and 40/41 case with a thinner movement leading to a case height in the 11-12.5mm range. As for the bracelet, it should be given a proper clasp - I'm sure Swatch group has the capital given its Moonswatch success to invest in a new bracelet. In short, while nice, the new 38 ATs have lost their originality. Whether it is vertical or horizontal, to me the Teak motif was and is the AT's identity, and shifting away from that is ultimately a mistake.

  • @Vess_Iossifov
    @Vess_Iossifov День тому

    I respect what you are doing on your channel. At the same time, I personally, am not interested in videos dedicated to specific watch model without you having the watch with you. Regards

  • @anthonystevens8683
    @anthonystevens8683 День тому

    I got a long discontinued pre METAS era 231.90.43.22.04.001 a long time ago and is possibly one of the reasons that I've stuck with it rather than considering a modern AT. A grade 5 titanium 'true' GMT with a flat white dial with blue applied markers and Omega logo and date at 6. I think I'll be sticking with my watch. It's simple, readable and light but I do like the Blaquaterra. If Omega made this a decade ago as you say where has the AT moved on to.

  • @Leftystrat
    @Leftystrat День тому

    Groundhog Day, gee it wouldn’t be the bracelet !🤡

  • @KeepingWatchUK
    @KeepingWatchUK День тому

    Nice enough but the Explorer &/or DateJust both beat it in every aspect.

  • @plantex625
    @plantex625 День тому

    Its literally a 2503 AT but with very minor changes, so the design has actually been around for almost 20 years. I own a smaller 36mm 2504 AT myself. The new one has PLCs (worse), its thicker (worse), numbers on the dial make it busier (worse), lumed indexes (better), better bracelet (better), and the date is at 6 (neutral). Its also well over 2x the price of 2503 in good condition on chrono24. So yeah, if you like this do yourself a favor and buy a 2503 AT on chrono24

  • @UltraDoug
    @UltraDoug День тому

    Reminds me of my GS SBGA467. Very similar overall style and black is underrated. This Omega ticks all the boxes for all the reasons you mentioned, Mr. Guy, and more. As I’m sure you’ve said, “simplicity is difficult. It leaves the watch nowhere to hide and everything needs to be perfect”……I dunno, maybe it was John Cleese who said it, but still true. You Britts are a clever bunch. 😉

  • @florianbartschiger1616
    @florianbartschiger1616 День тому

    I wear a 35mm Gloss Blaqua Terra from 2006. got it for 1800.- and the 2500 Co-Axial is cheep to service. Not tempted by this new one

  • @EDHBlvd
    @EDHBlvd День тому

    This watch is so boring I wouldn’t even notice it. Omega needs to try harder.

  • @dingodave3966
    @dingodave3966 День тому

    Dear Mr IDGuy, It’s the simple things. 🤷‍♂️

  • @kaczynski2333
    @kaczynski2333 День тому

    It's a lovely watch (i love the summer blue); but, at $11,700 AU they're taking the piss. Now, the Monta Noble is a whole other story. But even with the Monta, my wife and I could fly return to Japan, with enough money left over for a two weeks for the price of that watch. Watch people are strange.

  • @vantage789
    @vantage789 День тому

    Purchased a 124270 a few weeks and and absolutely love it. My only gripe, and I'm not quite certain it is a gripe, is the aggressive bracelet taper. I think I might prefer the proportions of the 14270 for this reason. Even the 1016 bracelet doesn't seem to taper the way the new one does. It just makes the watch look and feel a bit more delicate or daintier than it would otherwise.

  • @danemehring1029
    @danemehring1029 День тому

    I would take a Sinn 556i/ib over this as a watch in this sort of “tool watch” category should have minimal polishing. Two different price points though.

  • @actionarslan
    @actionarslan День тому

    Love the blaqua terra name the most. But then I love their lines but I don’t like the date window in any position other than 3. I’d rather have a no date. The telescoping crown would be hot!

  • @pedromanuellopez142
    @pedromanuellopez142 День тому

    Ironically, this comes very close to the first ATs with cal.2500. Those are still the most graceful, with the best overall proportions. There was an AT Chrono back then too. The black dial was stunning under any light, really deep, liquid and glossy, all at the same time.

  • @MasterChronometer
    @MasterChronometer День тому

    I loved the shades dials but the case is a smudge and scratch magnet. I think it would drive me crazy. The standard AT has a nice balance of both brushing and polishing.

  • @mrlong6267
    @mrlong6267 День тому

    I own both an omega Seamaster 300 professional and speedmaster yet the aqua terra never speaks to me due to its pointed hour markers. However I can see why it has mass appeal. Cheers to another successful week ID Guy. You are my favorite UA-camr whom I see once a week.😊

  • @aurelius388
    @aurelius388 День тому

    Maybe it is a bit nonsensical to ask for innovations in this hobby of ours - high-end mechanical watches.

    • @aurelius388
      @aurelius388 День тому

      As is so often the case online, instead of hearing you out, I paused the video to express my point regarding innovation vis-à-vis anachronistic mechanical watches. Then I continued watching - and got convinced by your views. That render at 7:10, of what the Aqua Terra could have been, is fantastic.

  • @rodsalvador3608
    @rodsalvador3608 День тому

    Anything with a rotating 12 hour bezel works just as well. I just traveled to the Galapagos with my P01. Swam with sea lions, hiked up Espanola lol etc etc. and just set the bezel to local time. Worked great. Normally use a GS SBGJ237 in the office. I don't feel very prestigious with either on my wrist lol, just love them.